Katie McGrath vs. Keira Knightley

McGrath’s name may not ring a bell to the casual observer, but the former Merlin star stunned us all by winning last year’s tournament. (Her fans are equally as tenacious as the Hiddlestoners.) Knightley, of course, is more well-known, but do her followers have the passion to pull off the upset?

NEXT: Helena Bonham Carter vs. Emma Thompson