Billie Piper vs. Kate Winslet

Piper was a pop star in Britain before she became this generation’s definitive Doctor Who companion, and since she left the series, she’s been crafting a career as a respected (and Olivier-nominated) stage actress. (She’s back for the show’s 50th anniversary special.) In this round, she faces a test with Kate Winslet, widely thought to be her generation’s greatest actress. (She’s just a Tony away from EGOT.) Who gets your vote?

NEXT: Adele vs. Samantha Barks