The Hive Recap: Governed By Sound Reason and True Religion

The Hive Writer’s Notes – Karen Walton and Graeme Manson

Dear #CloneClub,

After the Pope made the cover of Rolling Stone, the Hive decided Thomas, Helena’s Old World handler, needed to succumb to change. In other words – get whacked.

Welcome Henrik Johanssen to the Orphan Black fold, brought to you by Peter Outerbridge with rawboned righteousness. We introduce Johanssen inseminating a cow, as one does with a villain. Why? Because it’s kind of sick. Sick, swampy territory swimming with themes, memes, and suggesting the beautiful bio-horror to come in season two.


Henrik Johanssen, played by Peter Outerbridge.

Johanssen follows a different path—he “ran his faith through MIT,” and thus can interpret the science (and miracle) of Helena surviving a gunshot to the heart—she and Sarah are mirror twins. Yup, it’s a thing, a science thing, flagged last year and filed under “drop this headcannon in season two.” Yeeeees, the Hive are dirty rotten tricksters.


Rewrites at Johanssen Ranch.


Lighting Helena’s infirmary.

Locations like the Johanssen Ranch, The Birdwatchers’ faded mansion, and Aynsley’s funeral were chosen specifically to open up the show and explore cinematically different worlds. Director John Fawcett, DOP Aaron Morton and Locations Manager Bryn Garrison chose some logistically complex locations. In episode two we also step into a new set—Cosima’s lab. On the soundstage, it sits right next to Leekie’s office, but we use our exterior DYAD location to cross from Leekie’s gleaming glass side to the old wing basement that Cosima dryly calls “clone jail.” But really, how bad can jail be with Delphine in it? (Answer: This is Orphan Black.)

crazy2 crazy3
From the early story breaking, we knew the real centerpiece of the episode was “The Birdwatchers.” We conceived Mrs. S’s old network in the twin veins of Children of Men and the writers’ beloved Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy (the 1979 BBC mini-series). Like Mrs. S, Graeme is a bit of a birdwatcher. At least he can do a loon call by blowing into his hands (Canadians have weird skills). But it was Karen who—to put it in layman’s terms—wrote the shit out of The Birdwatchers. “Walty” and Maria Doyle Kennedy were already known, after a few pints, to hatch incendiary plots, so who better to reveal a deeper Mrs. S? So Sarah learns a few new tales about her step-mum, as we set the table for a betrayal. And the whole production got lucky when Maria found a remarkable foil in Nora McLennan, AKA Brenda the Birdwatcher, AKA RIP, AKA #birdsofafeather.


Nora McLennan at table with carving utensils; in background: Johanna Moore (First AD), Paulo Perin (Key Grip), and Aaron Morton (Director of Photography).

And talk about a weird location! The Birdwatchers’ house is actually an abandoned old mansion with one of those backstories about a rich man building it for a wife who never comes (or something… let’s embellish). Embellishing, the writers freaked themselves out in the creepy basements and dusty turrets, on the weird Masonic slogans and Canadiana stained glass. We even had to change Gamz’s (aka Graeme’s) pants after the basement tour; he still won’t—or can’t—talk about what he saw down there…. Suffice it to say, don’t mess with S.


The Birdwatchers’ mansion, built back in the 1930s.

So… now we know Mrs. S. Or at least we know she’ll pin a traitorous old friend to the table with the carving utensils and gun down her son to save Kira. And yet, Sarah still won’t trust her…

Us either. Don’t trust any of this! And poor Alison too! Felix helps her prove Donnie was really her monitor, then abandons her to hit the road with Sarah? That’s cold, Fee. You know she’s in the middle of rehearsals. None of this bodes well.

The Hive abides.


Graeme and Karen (aka Gamz and Walty)


Graeme Manson, graveside.


“Aynsley was one of favorite dearly departed characters from season one. So we really wanted to send her off in style. Her funeral had quite the suburban style.” – Graeme Manson


Karen Walton, looking like Sarah, on location at Johanssen Ranch.

NEXT: The Hive: Observations, Unexpected Results, and Mind-Benders

This story has multiple pages:

  • Ritu Gill

    If all the clones are genetically identical, then why does Cosima need to wear glasses….but the other clones do not….??

    • ana b.

      Hi! I’m sure there’s a full explanation somewhere but the short answer, if I’m not mistaken, is that she read like.. a lot, ever since she was a kid, so her eyes did the thing and BAM glasses needed.

    • Kele Cable

      As the character Cosima says in an episode, the clones may share identical genetics, but their environmental experiences are individual. Bad vision can be genetic, but the environment could be playing a causal role here.

  • Randy Simon

    Cosima’s glasses aren’t so puzzling; Helena’s hair is. How can she be blond? The easy answer is that she bleaches it, but somehow she doesn’t seem like the type who visits the beauty parlor for an occasional rinse…

    • fig

      Helena’s hair got me thinking too. I think the clones have natural curly hair, as we can see with Sarah this season. I assume Helena first bleached hers to get closer to the clones she had to kill without being recognized as an identical rightaway. It’s kind a sloppy idea since it makes her even more remarkable, but I guess that was all Thomas could think of and do it himself. And like you said, she is not the type that rinses it occasionally, so we can see the roots showing

      • shelly

        I think the blonde hair is tied more to the idea Tomas and/or his ilk planted into her head regarding her being “the original” and “the light”. It also complements the angel wings.

      • foolishcoyotedreams

        I think I love the idea that every 90 days Allison goes to an underground hair salon for a Canada-illegal Brazillian blowout to get her hair perfectly straightened. Even better, Donnie has to live with the rank odor of her head until she can wash her hair. . .

    • foolishcoyotedreams

      Dye is cheap and it’s sold in drugstores, discount stores, grocery stores. . .heck, I’ve seen it at $1 stores. It’s something you can get anywhere, so not a big deal to maintain. A GOOD blonde job would be one thing, but Helena’s got the white-blonde-cheapest-color-that-was-on-clearance-at-the-Family-Dollar thing going on. Of course, now I’m thinking of the crazy that is Helena sitting on the toilet in a t-shirt, waiting until she can rinse the dye out of her hair. . .probably painting her toe nails to pass the time.

    • sammysunshine

      Her colour looks like Dollarama Hair Dye to me…add the frying of her hair to the list of self harming behaviors she takes part in. I almost think she enjoys pain quite a lot. Remember her flagellating herself in season one? Seems like she learned it from Good Old Tomas.

      • 2imagine2

        You’re top comment on the CNN shooter article, but change your words…all you did is give out a twitter feed…..update your feed.

        • sammysunshine

          What does that even mean? It was information that people might want.

          • sammysunshine

            Also, I posted that comment when there was only three stilted paragraphs with sparse information because CNN had not posted anything much about it except that the shooter’s name (at that point) was unknown. Also, I’m not going to comment on this any further and hijack this Orhpan Black thread with negative things that happened last week.