Karen Gillan vs. Dame Judi Dench
OK, yeah, a truly bizarre faceoff. We expect even Gillan’s most fervent fans to have a moment of pause when voting against Ms. Dench — and then voting for Karen anyway, Dames be damned. (“Respect” didn’t stop Benedict Cumberbatch from routing Sir Ian McKellen in the men’s quarterfinals this year.) However, Dench fans are scrappy, taking down Helen Mirren in the last round.