Vote in the Anglo Fan Favorites Tournament, Men of 2013: Round 1

John Barrowman vs. Andrew Scott

(Photos: AP)

(Photos: AP)

It’s not easy to steal scenes from a) David Tennant or b) Benedict Cumberbatch, but Barrowman and Scott pulled it off as Doctor Who‘s Captain Jack and Sherlock‘s Moriarty, respectively. One’s most famous as a flirtatious, immortal time traveler; the other played a psychopathic, now-deceased supervillain. Who triumphs here?

NEXT: Stephen Fry vs. Hugh Laurie

This story has multiple pages: